The Church Is Not The Borg Collective

[Updated from the archives. The original version ran as a guest post at Aimee Byrd’s Housewife Theologian.]


            Aimee  Byrd posted an article about sisters and noted:

Aimee (right) and her sister, thinking up more things they can do to ... for their brother

Aimee (right) and her sister, thinking up more things they can do tofor their brother

“I always say that us sisters really help prepare our brothers for marriage to a woman. I shamefully take part of the credit of my brother’s gentlemanlike qualities. Unfortunately for him, he’s learned much of his patience by being sandwiched between two crazy sisters. Hopefully we are helping prepare our brothers in Christ for marriage to the Lord.”

This got me thinking about the Borg Collective.

On Star Trek, the Borg are a race that seeks perfection through abducting individuals and assimilating them into a collective intelligence, so that life and technology are wedded into a single unified organism. Hapless victims of Borg assimilation lose any semblance of their individuality, other than a resemblance of their former physical appearance.

Image - Agile Forest

Image – Agile Forest

They no longer think for themselves, and all their actions are directed by the collective as a whole. While there is a queen who appears to rule – much as a queen bee rules a hive – she is really no more an individual than any other member.

Some critics of Christianity suggest that the Church is not much different from the Borg Collective, as if we will all be assimilated and lose our individuality. But the Bible teaches something quite different.

Becoming who we are in Christ

It’s true that the Church is made up of women and men who are being conformed to the likeness of Christ. (Romans 8:29.) But we do not become interchangeable parts like cogs in a machine nor like Borg abductees in a collective. Rather, as C.S. Lewis points out, our differences sometimes can only exist when we are in something working together with others.

C.S. Lewis (Wikipedia)

C.S. Lewis

Things which are parts of a single organism may be very different from one another: things which are not, may be very alike. Six pennies are quite separate and very alike: my nose and my lungs are very different but they are only alive at all because they are parts of my body and share its common life. (C.S. Lewis, Mere Christianity, quoted in Derek Rishmawy’s Is Christianity Individualistic or Collectivist.)

The Bible shows this clearly in the Parable of the Talents where individuals are recognized for achieving different results with the different resources given them (Matthew 25:14-30), and in the passages listing the types of roles Christians can have as individuals in the Church such as being a pastor or an evangelist, giving and being merciful, praying or serving meals. (See, for example, Acts 6:1-7, Romans 12:3-8, 1 Corinthians 12:7-11 and Ephesians 4:11.) None of these acts are done alone even though carried out by individuals, of course, but then again nothing is done alone in any organization.

As we serve God and grow in Christ-likeness, we are told that it is God who is actually working in us to complete the work he began. (Philippians 1:6.) The experience of Christians through the centuries has borne witness to the fact that those who mature in Christ do get better and better at serving him. But that same witness nowhere supports the notion that these same maturing believers lose their individuality and become indistinguishable from one another.

Qing Dynasty Wedding Gown (Wikipedia)

Qing Dynasty Bridal Gown (Wikipedia)

I think Aimee’s assertion that women can prepare men for being Christ’s Bride is true; after all, men will join women in putting on a bridal gown because we are all getting married to the Groom. (Revelation 19:6-9.).

Apache Wedding Gown (a href="">Wikipedia)

Apache Bridal Gown (Wikipedia)

What’s really interesting to me is that men will experience that wedding as men just as women will experience it as women. We will experience it together as the Church, but since we each become more the person God made us to be as we grow in him we will also experience that wedding as individual men and women within the Church.

Victorian Wedding Gown (Wikipedia)

Victorian Bridal Gown

So men, what do you think of taking on the role of bride, not just as a member of the Church but also as the individual that God has made you to be?

And women, what do you think of sharing the role of Bride with your brothers in Christ, those Y chromosome carriers who (in this world at least) can never understand fully what it means to be a woman of God?

I don’t know what to think, at least not in the sense of fully understanding how it will be. But I do know that it will be wonderful.

Let the wedding begin!


This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to The Church Is Not The Borg Collective

  1. Beth Caplin says:

    Interesting perspective, especially since my wedding is in 29 days 🙂

  2. Tater says:

    Actually, I think you had it right from the start. Christianity is EXACTLY like the Borg Collective.You get assimilated (converted to Christianity) and lose the ability to think for yourself. You become a part of the Collective (mindless sheep in the church flock) and in turn try to assimilate (convert) others to your cause. You will be assimilated whether you like it or not (resistance is futile) and just like the Borg, Christians have no problem using violence against those who are not assimilated (damned heathens).

    • Tim says:

      Tater, I appreciate you commenting. Each of your assumptions are answered in the post above, but it’s up to you whether to believe it or not.

      P.S. If you think all Christians approve of violence, you should meet more Christians. (You should also read my post on not using a firearm.)

    • Anu Riley says:

      Tater, if it’s all right to share a bit of my personal story, I hope it will give you some food for thought. I’m not trying to change you or convert you, and I certainly won’t use violence to get my point across. “Christianity” probably exists as u describe in many pockets of society, but being His individual child is radically different than that. I have been walking with Him for over 20 years now and I am no “cookie cutter” Christian. In fact, it seems the Lord has done everything to “prevent me” from assimilating, losing my ability to think for myself, and although I do want others to know about Him, one of my closest friends is a non-Christian. I would never use any sort of violence or mind tricks to hurt her, simply to assimilate her. My parents and siblings are not Christians, and the same principles apply.

      I have actually “defied” more Christians in my lifetime, due to things I’ve said or done that rubbed them the wrong way or for other reasons I don’t fully know. This isn’t absolving me of responsibility on my part (if I truly did anything wrong, that’s on me). So I have known loneliness, been snubbed and rejected many times over.

      A true, born again child of God will absolutely “resist” being a part of ANY Borg “cube” where they are not allowed to be an individual. By the way, Jesus Himself absolutely resisted the “religious Borg cube” around Him. He refused to conform and had very few friends and followers by the end of His life

      Tim, I am a big Star Trek fan and I loved this analogy. Thank you for it.

  3. Pingback: A Plea To The Gospel Coalition: living up to your name | Tim's Blog – Just One Train Wreck After Another

Talk to me (or don't)

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.